When is a painting finished?

Share
Share

 

The other side of the blank canvas syndrome is the When is a painting finished question.

 

Today I bring you a creation that I started some time ago and have worked on, on and off, over the last few months. It’s one of those really exploratory pieces I’ve been doing, ones where I apply paint and then see where the image takes me, trusting in the process itself with my inner guide responding, together taking the artwork to a conclusion. One of the most difficult things with a painting like this, actually with any painting, is knowing when it’s finished. Questions arise like, Have I gone far enough? or worse perhaps, Have I gone too far? The explosive energy at the start of a piece is balanced out by the small incremental changes I make, by the pondering it takes to decide when to sign a painting and let it out into the world.

 

I recently found an unexpected way to help me answer the question of when is a painting finished.

 

I always let a painting ‘rest’ in the studio before deciding to do more to it but what I had never done before is hang it in my living space. I had reason to do this for the Fernwood Art Stroll in June (read my blog about the Stroll here), hanging paintings, mostly finished, all over the living room wall. I realized the next day that by doing this, a certain detachment from the painting begins to occur, it is now seen through my eyes as a viewer, not as the painter. I could ‘see’ that some works I thought were nearing completion instead still had much to be done whereas others, like the one I will show you below, said, I am done, I ask no more of you, the conversation is now finished.

 

So here’s the process – start to finish.

 

1. The painting begins with a wash of randomly applied fluid acrylic paint
1. The painting begins with a wash of randomly applied fluid acrylic paint.
2. A turquoise paint was also applied and then the whole was covered by a veil of thin white paint into which I scratched to reveal, in parts, the saturated colour beneath. (I am sorry I am missing a photo before the white was applied.)
2. A turquoise paint was also applied and then the whole was covered by a veil of thin white paint into which I scratched to reveal, in parts, the saturated colour beneath. (I am sorry I don’t have a photo before the white was applied.)

 

3. I then went in with charcoal and made marks as the piece suggested. This I sealed in with a coat of medium (so it wouldn't smudge).
3. I then went in with charcoal and made marks as the piece suggested. This I sealed in with a coat of medium (so it wouldn’t smudge).

 

4. The finished piece. As you can see, I added teabags. They don't show up quite as boldly in real life! Gail Sibley, "Untitled (as yet)," acrylic and teabags on canvas, 16 x 12 "
4. The finished piece. As you can see, I added teabags to add dimension and to say something more. (They don’t show up quite as boldly in real life!) Gail Sibley, “Untitled (as yet),” acrylic and teabags on canvas, 16 x 12 in

 

Here’s a closeup:

5. Gail Sibley, "Untitled (as yet)," acrylic and teabags on canvas, 16 x 12 " - detail
5. Gail Sibley, “Untitled (as yet),” acrylic and teabags on canvas, 16 x 12 ” – detail

 

And to finish (hah hah), here are a few quotes related to the question, When is a painting finished?

 

Experimentalists never know when their work is finished.

~ Daniel H. Pink

 

Genius begins great works; labor alone finishes them.

~ Joseph Joubert  (he had some other really great quotes! – click on his name to see some)

 

Great is the art of beginning, but greater is the art of ending.

~ Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

 

While adding the finishing touches to a painting might appear insignificant, it is much harder to do than one might suppose…

~ Claude Monet

 

A painting is finished when to have done less would be considered a sin and more a crime.

~ Ted Godwin

 

A picture is finished when all trace of the means used to bring about the end has disappeared.

~ James McNeil Whistler

 

A painting is finished when the artist says it is finished.

~ Rembrandt

 

 

I’d love to hear what you think of my new piece. Any ideas for a title??

Also, I’d appreciate your thoughts about the question, When is a painting finished?

 

 

That’s all I have for now. Thanks for reading and sharing!!

~ Gail

 

 

 

4 thoughts on “When is a painting finished?”

  1. I like it very much can understand why its hard to decide when you are finished a number of times through its development it appeared finished to me but must agree with Rembrandt the painter knows when. the concept of the work telling you is new to me but very informative Could you name it Romp or some derivative???

    1. Glad you like it Sandy – certainly different for me!! Funny you mention about liking different stages. That’s what makes it so difficult to continue sometimes. And yet, the painting still speaks, wanting something more, and so I obey 🙂 I appreciate the name suggestion. Tell me more about how you came up with it please!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

How to pastel website logo

Sign Up

Hi! Thanks for your interest in my work. Please join my mailing list! You’ll receive my blog, HowToPastel and lots of other goodies that I share with my communities! 

Your email is precious and will not be exchanged, lent, rented, sold, or become viewable by any third party.